I've sat through the past two English classes learning and discussing the ideas of Existentialism, and forming my own opinions on the subject. I'm glad I finally get the opportunity to voice my opinion on it in a non-confrontational way. Multiple times Mr. Mullins has asked us questions about Existentialism and "selfishness" not based on the ideals and morals that religions explicitly say or spell out for us. I have felt uncomfortable with the topic for this reason: Christianity is not just my religion, it is my faith and what everyday from here on out in my life will be centered on. It is impossible for me to think through Existentialism without also keeping God in mind and His role in these ideas. One of the main points of Existentialism is the idea that we have no purpose until we figure it out ourselves simply by experiencing life. I know there are many people out there in the world that don't even believe God exists, but I don't understand how one can lay their head down at night and think they have no purpose. I am far from a perfect person, but I wake up everyday knowing that my purpose in life is to live as Christ did, and to spread God's Word to others. God created me for something. This is one way in which Existentialism clashes with Christianity. Another source I found defines Existentialism like this "On the testimony and evidence of existence, life is patently chaotic, incoherent, meaningless, and hence absurd; consequently, the only responsible and honest intellectual and emotional response is to turn to the imperatives of the human spirit, to assert the freedom and autonomy of the self in order to impose meaningful form on the chaotic flux of existence." (Clifford Edwards) I find it hard to agree with someone when they call my life meaningless. Jesus the Son of God died on the cross so that I may have a chance to have a life in Christ. Now I find it hard to believe God would send His son to die for a bunch of humans' whose lives are meaningless. I think the whole idea of Existentialism makes us only think about ourselves. It makes us consider ourselves above others, and figure out who we are before we can help or acknowledge anyone else's importance. Unfortunately, I can't sit back and tell everyone reading this blog that Existentialism is a wrong concept because at the end of the day when I consider the world as it is today, Existentialism ideas can be found anywhere and everywhere.
Maybe this blog is long and absurd, and you might think that it doesn't even make a valid point, but I had to express why this topic made me feel a little squirmy and uncomfortable. At the end of the day, it goes against what I spend everyday pursuing and believing in and is therefore a hard concept for me to handle. I felt the need to share some of my thoughts, even if they didn't make sense to everyone else.
To do is to be stands out in my mind because i can apply it to some of my christian values to identify myself,i do the actions and of a christian therefore I am a christian. I agree with you though that putting discussions of existentialism against religiou views makes me uncomfortable too. Also in the video you linked the little girl dancing in the middle of the subway reminded me of the girl dancing after her home is destroyed from the book we read called "The Things They Carried."
ReplyDeleteWhat really caught my eye was when you started talking about some people who don't think they really have a purpose in life because they do not believe in God or some other reason. So how would they find out they that they actually do have a purpose?
ReplyDeleteNo need to feel awkward or "squirmy." If you're a person who's taken time to think through these things, then they're obviously important to you. Anything that questions that has to make you feel uncomfortable. However, I think it's healthy to not see this as a threat, but as a way to strengthen your beliefs. Don't ever hesitate to voice opposing viewpoints in class.
ReplyDeleteAnd there are Christian philosophers who have reconciled the ideas of existentialism with Christianity, though I have to admit, I don't know much about it. Check out http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_existentialism if you're curious.
Oh, and thanks for reminding me of this song. I haven't heard it in a long time. It always reminds me of my first year of teaching for some reason.